Reviewer's Score Reviewer's Comments

___ Character (-0, -2, or -5)

 You need not explain if you award '-0'.

___ Questions (-0 or U)

 You need not explain if you award '-0'.

Organization:
___ Introduction (-0, -2, or U)
___ Progression (-0 or -2)

 You need not explain if you award '-0'.

Sources:
___ Dependence (-0, -3, or U)
___ Citation (-0, -2, or U)

 You need not explain if you award '-0'.
___ Style (-0, -1, -2, or U) You need not explain if you award '-0'.

___ Reasoning (0-30)

 Evaluate the quality of reasoning and defend whatever score you award. Be specific!
____ Total
(Reviewer)		 Reviewer: ____________________________
Date given to reviewer: _________ init: ___
Date returned to writer: _________ init: ___

___ Essay
(Coach)

___ Review
(Coach)